Honey and Natural Process in Colombia: The Alternatives to Washed
Washed coffee built Colombia's name. Naturals and honeys are the newer, riskier lane — and on a growing number of farms you can now taste the same tree processed three ways in one sitting.
On this page
For most of the twentieth century, asking a Colombian farm about processing was a short conversation. There was one method. It was washed. The infrastructure, the training, the buying standards and the national reputation were all built around it.
That has changed within the last fifteen years or so, and it has changed fast. Walk into a specialty-focused farm in Quindío or Huila today and you may be offered the same variety, from the same harvest, finished three different ways. Understanding what separates them is the single most useful thing you can carry into a farm visit.
The only variable that matters
Strip away the terminology and every processing method is answering one question: how much of the fruit stays attached to the seed while it dries?
- Washed — skin off, mucilage fully removed before drying. The seed dries naked in its parchment.
- Honey — skin off, but some or all of the mucilage deliberately left on during drying.
- Natural — nothing removed. The whole cherry dries intact, fruit and all, and is hulled much later.
That is the entire distinction. Everything else — the flavour differences, the risk profiles, the price gaps — follows from it. The fruit is sugar, and sugar left in contact with the seed while it dries does things.
What natural process does
In a natural, the picked cherry goes straight to drying without being pulped at all. Over the following weeks the fruit shrivels around the seed, and while it does, the sugars and the fermenting flesh drive flavour compounds inward.
The results are unmistakable and polarising. Naturals push heavy fruit — strawberry, blueberry, overripe stone fruit — with a thicker body, lower perceived acidity and a sweetness that can edge toward boozy or jammy. Done well, they are extraordinary. Done badly, they taste rotten, and the line between the two is thinner than anyone would like.
The critical requirement is airflow and constant attention. A cherry drying whole has vastly more moisture to lose than a bare parchment seed, and it is doing it inside a sugar-rich skin that mould finds ideal. Batches must be turned repeatedly, sometimes many times a day, so nothing sits.
What honey process does
Honey sits between the two, and the name has nothing to do with honey as an ingredient — it describes the sticky, amber appearance of the drying parchment.
The cherry is depulped normally, but instead of fermenting and washing the mucilage away, the farm leaves a controlled proportion of it on and dries the coffee like that. Producers commonly describe the result by colour, roughly tracking how much mucilage was retained and how much light the drying beds got:
| Style | Mucilage retained | Typical character |
|---|---|---|
| Yellow honey | Least | Closest to washed; light sweetness, clarity preserved |
| Red honey | Moderate | Rounder body, caramel and red fruit, softened acidity |
| Black honey | Most, slow shaded drying | Dense, syrupy, closest to a natural |
These are working descriptions rather than a regulated standard, and one farm's red honey is another's black. Do not treat the labels as precise across producers — treat them as a signal of intent within a single farm's range.
Processing vocabulary in specialty coffee is unregulated and moves quickly. Terms like anaerobic, carbonic maceration, extended fermentation and thermal shock all describe real technique, but there is no authority policing their use. Ask the farm to describe what they physically did rather than accepting the label.
Why Colombia came late to this
Three reasons, all practical.
The climate fights you. Naturals want dry air and steady sun. The Colombian coffee belt offers humidity, afternoon cloud and rain distributed through the year. Drying a whole cherry safely under those conditions requires either luck or infrastructure.
The system was built for washed. Decades of extension work, equipment subsidy, quality standards and buyer expectation were aligned behind a single method. Deviating meant working against the grain of everything a grower had been taught.
The buyer had to exist first. Naturals and honeys cost more to produce and carry far more downside risk. Nobody takes that on to sell into the commodity market at commodity prices. It only became rational once specialty buyers appeared who would pay a premium for a distinctive lot — which, for Colombia, is a relatively recent development.
What unlocked it on the ground was drying infrastructure, principally the marquesina — the parabolic solar dryer, a plastic-roofed tunnel that gives sun and airflow while keeping rain off. Once farms had reliable covered drying, experimenting with fruit-on methods stopped being reckless.
The farms around Armenia and the wider Quindío department include several specialty-focused operations running experimental lots alongside their standard washed production, which is what makes a genuine three-way comparison possible.
The risk, stated plainly
A washed lot that goes wrong is usually a disappointing lot. A natural that goes wrong can be a total loss — mould, phenolic off-flavours, an entire batch of cherry that has to be dumped.
The risk multiplies with volume. This is why experimental processing in Colombia tends to be done in small, carefully watched batches, often on raised beds where a farm can see every layer, rather than across a whole harvest. A farm telling you they process everything as naturals is either very confident, very well equipped, or overselling.
It also explains the price. When you see a farm shop selling its natural lot at a substantial premium over its washed, that gap is covering real losses on batches that did not make it, not just marketing.
Tasting all three side by side
If a farm offers a comparative tasting across processes, take it. It is the fastest possible education, and it costs an hour.
The conditions that make it meaningful:
- Same farm, same harvest, same variety. Otherwise you are tasting the difference between two coffees, not between two processes.
- Same roast profile. A darker roast on one sample will drown the comparison entirely.
- Blind, if they will do it. Knowing which cup is the natural makes you taste the natural.
- Washed first. Work from the cleanest to the most intense. Doing it in reverse means the natural coats your palate and flattens everything after it.
What most people find is not the answer they expected. Newcomers often assume they will prefer the loud one, and a good share of them come away preferring the washed — the clarity is easier to keep drinking. Others find the washed sample thin once they have had the natural. Both reactions are legitimate and neither indicates a better coffee.
Naturals and honeys command higher prices because they are riskier and scarcer, not because they are objectively superior. A well-made washed Colombian is not a lesser product. Buy the one you actually want to drink tomorrow morning.
Where to find it
Comparative processing tastings are not standard on the general-audience farm tour. The big daily tours near the tourist towns are built around a single walk-through of the washed chain, which is the right call for most visitors.
To get the three-way comparison you generally need to look for tours that describe themselves as specialty, experimental or cupping-focused, and be prepared to pay more and spend longer — often a half or full day rather than ninety minutes. Farms in Quindío, Caldas and Huila are the likeliest to run them, though individual producers experimenting with process now exist in every coffee department in the country.
Specialty producers running experimental lots are often small and rurally sited, without the shuttle arrangements the large tourist farms maintain. A car turns a two-connection expedition into a straightforward morning. Compare rental cars.
Ask one question when you book: do you process anything other than washed on this farm, and can we taste it against the washed? The answer sorts the options quickly, and it tells you whether you are booking an education or a walk in the sun.